[I know, I know. Posting about the last of the prequels is so last week. But I saw the film on Saturday night and have only had the chance to post about it now, and if I don't weigh in with an opinion then I'll be stripped of my geek credentials once and for all.]
From a certain point of view, George Lucas had an easy job in bringing his saga back to the point where we came in (more or less) some 28 years ago. After all, at least this time round he knew exactly where his characters would end up and roughly how he had to get them there. As long as he gave us a few key moments – the rise of Emperor Palpatine, a certain princess-turned-senator giving birth to twins, a kick-ass lightsabre duel between master and pupil, the first appearance of an iconic black helmet, the dismemberment of Jar-Jar Binks (I can dream, can't I?) – pretty much any minor misstep could be forgiven.
The trouble is, it wasn't that simple in practice. Since Lucas returned to his most famous work he's demonstrated again and again that either he'd lost his touch or else his collaborators some twenty years ago deserved more credit than they got for making his story come to life on screen. Could the man who gave us Jar-Jar Binks really do justice to the seduction of Anakin Skywalker by Emperor Palpatine?
Happily, the answer is "Yes." Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith is much the best of the prequel trilogy, and while Lucas' dialogue leaves a lot to be desired the actors mostly make it work this time round. If you're still willing to go where George Lucas wants to take you, you'll more than get your money's-worth. If anything, the problem with this film is that it tries to pack too much plot into 140 minutes: it might have been better to devote a lot less time to wandering around finding little Anakin in Episode I and get to the meat of the storyline that much sooner.
In the end, the good news is that – with the notable but entirely predictable exception of the dialogue – pretty much every element of Revenge of the Sith is between 20% and 50% better than the other two prequels. The special effects technology is used to paint some truly striking cityscapes and spacecraft that flew right off the cover of a 50s SF novel. The action sequences are mostly very good indeed, particularly the ones involving Yoda – the scenes where he avoids an ambush, and another when he faces off with Darth Sidious, are marvelous. There's still the occasional misuse of CGI to depict humans leaping around turning somersaults in slightly unnatural ways, but that seems to be a trap just about every large-scale SF or fantasy film falls into nowadays. (OK, strictly speaking that's Jedi and Sith leaping around, but my general point still stands, just as it did for a certain elf in another major trilogy I could name.) Oh yes, and Yoda gets one of his very best lines in the entire trilogy:
"If so powerful you are…"
[Twirls lightsabre, lights up]
"…why leave?"
Gary Farber has found a copy of the Revenge of the Sith script online and made a series of posts discussing some of the passages which were edited down or skipped completely in the final release. As Gary notes, it's a shame that Jimmy Smits got so little to do yet again – he got more lines this time round, but I for one wanted to see more of the man who worked with Amidala in the Senate to resist Palpatine's rise and who would end up as Leia's adoptive father. I'll be interested to see how much omitted material ends up on the DVD release.