I was out last night seeing X-Men: The Last Stand so I didn’t get a chance to post any comments until this evening. I think the simplest approach is to adapt what I said about the film in an email earlier this evening:
The Good: Most of the returning cast can deliver even a lacklustre script well enough to sell it. The exception is Halle Berry, who is the leader of the X Men in the field this time round but completely fails to convince. (It’s not that she’s a bad actress, but somehow putting her in a superhero film seems to leech away her talent. OK, so she was given a terrible kiss-off line to deliver in the first film, but this time round she got the extra lines she wanted and a big, dramatic story that put her in a leadership role so what other explanation is there?)
Kelsey Grammer’s Hank McCoy is much better than I’d expected, though I still can’t quite bring myself to like the makeup job. (Also, there’s nary a mention in the film that the man is a brilliant scientist. All it would have taken was one scene showing him, say, analysing the ‘mutant cure’ to determine that it was what it said it was!) The pick of the new characters (OK, new actors) in this instalment, though, is Ellen Page’s Kitty Pryde: she’s not given nearly enough screen time to properly develop her character, and her romantic interest should be Piotr Rasputin not Bobby Drake (dammit!), but she’s an engaging presence; her running battle with Juggernaut is one of the highlights of the film. If they’re going to do a Wolverine spinoff, I hope they can find an excuse to have him team up with Kitty. (Though I gather the Wolverine film is going to be a prequel, so Kitty would presumably not be born yet. Shame.) Alternatively, someone tell Joss Whedon to forget about Wonder Woman and do Shadowcat: The Movie.
The Bad: Vinny Jones is just about as bad a Cain Marko as you’d expect if you’ve had the misfortune of seeing his other big screen outings. The other members of the Brotherhood are mostly anonymous, brought on to use their power once during an action scene. Also, they completely wasted Jamie Madrox and Warren Worthington III, neither of whom really needed to be here.
The Ugly: If you’re looking for an adaptation of the original X-Men Dark Phoenix saga then this isn’t the film you’re looking for. The film badly needs another half hour of quieter character scenes to balance all the widescreen mayhem.
On the other hand, there’s no denying that the sheer weight of mutant-on-mutant mayhem looks pretty impressive and I suspect that non-comic fans will enjoy it quite a bit. Personally, I feel mildly positive about the experience: X-Men: The Last Stand isn’t a patch on the first two films, but it’s by no means a disaster and it does bring the story to an interesting place. I probably will go and see it again before long, and that’s not something I expected to say going in.
(NB: you definitely want to stay on to the very end of the credit sequence.)
Gary Farber has posted a collection of links to early reviews.